Has Implementation of Citizenship Amendment Act Been Halted?

More than 200 petitions requested a stay on the implementation of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). The Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing in April 2024 to address these requests.

Citizenship Amendment Act


The anchor announces that there is no immediate stay on the CAA, and the next hearing is scheduled for April 9th.

Anchor: Today, we have with us Ranjan Nayak, an experienced political analyst, who is going to explain to us current complex political topics in simple language. Ranjan, explain to our viewers what is happening between the Center, Supreme Court, and petitions about the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA).

Legal Challenges and Court Proceedings

Ranjan: Thank you for having me here. Over 200 petitions were seeking a stay on implementation of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). So the Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing for April 2024 to address these issues. The court has asked the central government to file a response or reply to these pleas. This indicates that the court wants to hear the government’s side of the issue before making any decisions or taking further action. I would like to read the exact statement by CJI DY Chandrachud.

Anchor: Yes, please.

Ranjan: Thank you, “Let submissions be made on the stay application limited to 5 pages till April 2. Let respondents file a 5-page reply to the application by April 8. So we will have all the essential arguments a day before the hearing,” says CJI Chandrachud.

Contention of Petitions

Anchor: what is the argument of Petitions?

Ranjan: See, the primary argument of the petitions is that the CAA violates the Indian constitution by excluding Muslims from its provisions. They say the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) is discriminatory and undermines the secular principles of the Indian constitution. Muslims from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan are not eligible for citizenship.

Anchor: some Petition were also seeking assurance regarding the implementation of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) during the legal process, what’s that?

Ranjan: Yes, Indira Jaisingh, a senior advocate representing the petitioners, requested Solicitor General Tushar Mehta to make a statement ensuring that no one would be granted citizenship under the law, in response to this Mehta said he could not make such a statement.

 IUML’s Application and Government’s Response

Anchor: On March 12, 2024, The Indian Union Muslim League(IUML) applied to halt the Implementation of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). What happened to that?

Ranjan: Yes, they applied. But as you know the centre notified the rules for implementing the CAA, four years and three months after its passage. An interesting thing is this move comes ahead of the announcement of dates for the Lok Sabha elections.

 Anchor: thank you Ranjan for joining us.

 Ranjan: My pleasure.

Ranjan: The Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) is a contentious law that seeks to provide citizenship to persecuted Minorites from neighbouring countries. However, it has faced criticism for excluding Muslims from the same countries and violating the principles of secularism in the Indian constitution. Stay tuned. We’ll keep you updated.

Dear Readers,

If you wish to read our other blogs, click here

If you wish to read a blog from another website, click here

FAQ

1. What is the current status of the legal challenges to the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA)?

The Supreme Court has not issued an immediate stay on the CAA. The next hearing is scheduled for April 9th, 2024.

2. What are the main arguments of the petitions against the CAA?

The petitions argue that the CAA violates the Indian constitution by excluding Muslims from its provisions, which they see as discriminatory and against the secular principles of the constitution.

3. What was the Supreme Court’s directive regarding the stay application and response filing?

The Supreme Court directed that submissions on the stay application be limited to 5 pages and filed by April 2nd. Respondents were asked to file a 5-page reply by April 8th.

Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top